next up previous index
Next: Optimality Up: Criteria for Parameter Estimation Previous: Correctness

Instability

The value of the energy change can be used to measure the (local) stability of with respect to a certain configuration . Ideally, we want to be very low and to be very high, such that is very large, for all . In such a situation, is expected to be a stable minimum where the stability is said w.r.t. perturbations in the observation and w.r.t. the local minimum problem with the minimization algorithm.

The smaller is , the larger is the chance with which a perturbation to the observation will cause to become negative to violate the correctness. When , no longer corresponds to the global minimum. Moreover, we assume that configurations f whose energies are slightly higher than are possibly local energy minima at which an energy minimization algorithm is most likely to get stuck.

Therefore, the energy difference, i.e. the local stabilities should be enlarged. One may define the global stability as the sum of all . For reasons to be explained later, instability,   instead of stability, is used for evaluating .

The local instability for a correct estimate is defined as

 

where . It is ``local'' because it considers only one It is desirable to choose such that the value of is small for all . Therefore, we defined the following global p-instability of

 

where . The total global p-instability of is

In the limit as , we have (This is because for the p-norm defined by , we have .)

 

is due solely to f having the smallest or largest value.

Unlike the global stability definition, the global instability treats each item in the following manner: those f having smaller (larger ) values affect in a more significant way. For p=2, for example, the partial derivative is

where takes the linear form (7.2). The smaller the is, the more it affects . This is desirable because such f are more likely than the others to violate the correctness, because their values are small, and should be more influential in determining .